Consider the following sentences: 1. Crossing the playground after the assembly, a sudden shower drenched the new teacher. 2. The Vice Principal suggested that we should start the practical examination an hour early. 3. The advice that the counsellor gave to the Class XII students were practical and timely. 4. Nobody except the accountant and me knew the password for the fee portal. Which of the sentences given above are grammatically correct?
- (a) 1 and 3 only
- (b) 2 and 4 only
- (c) 2, 3 and 4 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 4 only
2 and 4 only. Sentence 2 is correct: suggest takes a that-clause with should + bare verb, or the bare verb alone (Oxford Learner's, suggest: "It has been suggested that bright children take their exams early", and in British English "… should take their exams early"; ch10 H, pattern 22). Sentence 4 is correct: except is a preposition, so it takes the object form me, and the subject is the singular nobody (ch10 H, pattern 21; D.3, rule 2). Sentence 1 is wrong: an opening participle must belong to the subject of the main clause, and a shower cannot cross a playground, so the participle dangles (ch10 L, pattern 38). It could read "As the new teacher was crossing the playground after the assembly, a sudden shower drenched her." Sentence 3 is wrong: advice is uncountable (Oxford Learner's marks it [uncountable]) and takes a singular verb: "was practical and timely" (ch10 H, pattern 19). (a) accepts both faulty sentences and rejects both correct ones; (c) accepts sentence 3, where the plural students just before the verb tempts were; (d) accepts sentence 1, the dangling participle.